Explore
Gaia Soulmates
 Advertising keeps Gaia free! Interested in sponsoring us?

Sam Harris On Islam and Multiculturalism

Posted on May 5th, 2008 by ~C4Chaos : (hyper)linker ~C4Chaos

(Crossposted from www.c4chaos.com)


Sam Harris just published another impassioned essay on The Huffington Post. He defended Geert Wilders's film, Fitna and then went on to criticize (and righly so) the climate of multiculturalism in Western culture. Very ballsy. Below are some key quotes.

"The point is not (and will never be) that some free person spoke, or wrote, or illustrated in such a manner as to inflame the Muslim community. The point is that only the Muslim community is combustible in this way. The controversy over Fitna, like all such controversies, renders one fact about our world especially salient: Muslims appear to be far more concerned about perceived slights to their religion than about the atrocities committed daily in its name. Our accommodation of this psychopathic skewing of priorities has, more and more, taken the form of craven and blinkered acquiescence." ....

"The connection between the doctrine of Islam and Islamist violence is simply not open to dispute. It's not that critics of religion like myself speculate that such a connection might exist: the point is that Islamists themselves acknowledge and demonstrate this connection at every opportunity and to deny it is to retreat within a fantasy world of political correctness and religious apology. Many western scholars, like the much admired Karen Armstrong, appear to live in just such a place. All of their talk about how benign Islam "really" is, and about how the problem of fundamentalism exists in all religions, only obfuscates what may be the most pressing issue of our time: Islam, as it is currently understood and practiced by vast numbers of the world's Muslims, is antithetical to civil society. ....

"This is what we owe the true moderates of the Muslim world: we must hold their co-religionists to the same standards of civility and reasonableness that we take for granted in all other people. Only our willingness to openly criticize Islam for its all-too-obvious failings can make it safe for Muslim moderates, secularists, apostates--and, indeed, women--to rise up and reform their faith.

"And if anyone in this debate can be credibly accused of racism, it is the western apologists and "multiculturalists" who deem Arabs and Muslims too immature to shoulder the responsibilities of civil discourse." [read more]


Access_public Access: Public 2 Comments Print views (427)  
Balder : Kosmonaut
35 minutes later
Balder said

Hi, C4, thank you for posting this.  I read it earlier this morning when you first added the link to Gaia.  I disagree with Sam Harris about a number of things, but here I think he is right:  to refrain from critiquing the extremism, cruelty, and violence present in certain branches of Islam as it is currently practiced today out of multicultural sensitivity is misguided and harmful.  There are most certainly political, postcolonial dimensions to the anger and aggression we are witnessing, but there is no question that Islamic teachings are being used to sanction political violence, and this trend can and should be rightly condemned.

I agree with him also that it would be racist to assume that Muslims are not “mature enough” to engage in civil discourse, but on the other hand, as Wilber would point out, v-Memetic factors may interfere with the success of a dialogical approach.  However, Islamic culture and religion are not a monolithic whole, and encompass a range of v-Memetic perspectives, so while some individuals may not be interested in civil discourse, others may be – particularly if, as he says, enough individuals speak out so that it becomes safer to do so.


But the way forward won't be easy.  Ideally, moderates and progressives within the tradition would lead the way.  But currently, not many appear to be doing so… 

HeyOK : Bridgebuilder
about 17 hours later
HeyOK said

Thanks for this and link.
Blessings, David

You have to be a Gaia member to post comments.
Login or Join now!